The pizza was hot, fresh and clearly made with high-quality ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and sliced buffalo mozzarella cheese. 2 large pizzas was perfect for 4 people and we had plenty of leftovers! The mozzarella sticks came out room temperature and are very overpriced for what they are, but it didn't ruin the experience.
Stopped by on Columbus Day with my wife. Okay if you want pizza but sandwich menu limited. Had chicken cheese steak which was just okay. Wife enjoyed 2 meatball appetizer. Watch out if waitress offers you a refill on non alcoholic beverage. Refilled my ice tea and wife’s half empty glass. Got charged $12 for four beverages. Won’t be back!!!
Pro Tips:
- Try the simple, yet crispy white pizza with mozzarella, garlic
Highly recommend getting your pizza fix here.
- Ask for a table outside by the water
- It's not fancy outside, paper plates and plastic cups
- Definitely can get a table outside in the off-season
oil, olive oil ($15 or $19)
Best pizza on the island. Everything came out tasty and our service was great. It's super quiet in the off-season! Brianna was a wonderful server and we loved her upbeat, positive attitude.
First time here, friendly staff, very attentive to our table and the food was very good. Only downside is it's a little pricey. Would come back though. Edit: Our server was Timothy. He's great the whole time. Very good waiter.
- If you have an allergy, try the gluten free personal pizza and add your own toppings (additional charge for toppings)
If you like pizza void of sauce but covered in six pounds of cheese well this is the pizza for you. Crust was dry and tasteless. This use to be our favorite pizza place every summer we stayed in Avalon but sad to say not anymore.
The only people who will enjoy pizza from this new take on the old Stone Harbor Pizza are people who don't know what it used to be, or people who would rather pay for the homogenized "Reeds" look on the front window instead of decent pizza or a decent menu. Besides serving nothing but overpriced pizza that is only the shadow of the awesome shore pizza this establishment used to sell (literally the menu is less than a page long), the wait staff teenagers are slow, disengaged, and relatively incompetent. We received our pizza before the "appetizers" we ordered, which consisted of french fries and chicken fingers that should have been on the kids menu. There wasn't anything else to order but wings. The pizza itself was awful- oily to the point of dripping off the pie, with different crust that couldn't hold the cheese, and the tables on the deck are so small, that once they put the pizza down, there was no room for the dish you need to eat it. A couple of badly placed awnings do nothing to cover the tables, so don't think about going from 4-7PM, or eat inside while passersby gawk at you. We've been coming to Stone Harbor pizza for more than 19 years, and sadly, it seems this tradition is now over for us. Sometimes the best way to keep a good thing going is to LEAVE IT ALONE. If I could give it less than a star, I would.
Stone Harbor Pizza Pub is a US Restaurant based in Stone Harbor, New Jersey. Stone Harbor Pizza Pub is located at 315 96th St, Stone Harbor, NJ 08247, USA.
Please contact with Stone Harbor Pizza Pub using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Stone Harbor Pizza Pub opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.